Carpet or Vinyl Flooring?

Carpet or Vinyl Flooring? 8 Things to Consider

Faced with choosing floor coverings for domestic or commercial use, what would be your preference – carpeting or vinyl? It’s a tough call, and in making the decision you would probably be well advised to enlist the help of a professional flooring company with experience of various types of flooring, like Paul Ealey of Bath.

When all is said and done, though, the choice is yours – down to your personal taste and inclination, while weighing up the professional advice and reviews of various products.

When deciding between vinyl flooring and carpeting for your home or business premises there are some important things to consider.

Before we list those, let us just point out that according to the latest AMA Research (leading specialist market research provider into the UK building and construction industries) report on the UK floor coverings market:

“Vinyl is increasingly the product of choice in both the contract and domestic floor covering sectors, with growth driven primarily by the popularity of LVT, the fastest growing sector in the UK flooring market.”

Comparing Vinyl Flooring & Carpeting

1. Durability & Wear

Vinyl flooring is generally more durable and resistant to scratches, tears, scuffs, stains and dents than carpeting in high traffic areas, especially if it is of a good quality, constructed with several layers and has a sturdy transparent top layer to protect the colour and design from wear and tear. If you’re covering a heavy duty floor setting, opt for vinyl flooring with a wear layer of at least 0.5mm thick (known as 20 mil). Normal is considered to be 0.3mm (12 mil).

Contrary to what you may imagine, few carpets stay on the floor long enough to actually wear through, regardless of how heavy foot traffic is. With carpeting wear and tear is more often evident in the matting, soiling and fading of the fibres. The most durable type of carpeting for busy areas is nylon, followed by polypropylene. A lot depends on the construction of the carpeting with things like the density of the tufts, pile height, and underlay playing a role in how long the carpeting will stand up to wear and tear.

2. Maintenance

Vinyl flooring is undoubtedly easier to clean and keep hygienic than carpeting. All it needs is regular sweeping and occasional mopping. It shrugs off liquid and therefore is unlikely to stain. If you use LVT (Luxury Vinyl tiles) or vinyl plank flooring it’s easy to replace damaged tiles or planks with new ones.

Carpeting – even if it is treated with a fabric protector – can soak up moisture and dirt and debris can penetrate the fibres. Regular vacuuming is necessary to keep dirt at bay, and spot cleaning of spills straightaway will keep it looking clean for longer. Carpet manufacturers recommend professional carpet cleaning periodically.

3. Water Resistance

Vinyl flooring is made mainly of vinyl resins and plasticisers, so therefore it is resistant to moisture. This makes it perfect for use in kitchens, bathrooms, boot rooms, utility rooms and entrance halls.

Carpeting, being fibrous, absorbs water and if it stays damp too long can become mouldy.

4. Comfort and warmth

There’s no doubt that carpeting underfoot is more cosy than vinyl, especially during the winter. It also acts as insulation, helping to retain heat in your home or workplace. Carpets also keep things quieter, dampening the decibels in a noisy environment.

Vinyl needn’t be written off because it is hard and cold, however. There are various foam underlays available which provide a cushioning effect, adding insulation and warmth to a space – and you can always opt to have underfloor heating.

5. Style & Aesthetics

It’s difficult to pick a winner here, because both vinyl flooring and carpeting come in a vast array of styles, colours and patterns to suit any interior scheme or situation.

If anything, one could probably say vinyl has the edge, because it can be designed to mimic just about any surface covering, from ceramic tiles and wood to all kinds of natural stone – even bare cement if you want the minimalist industrial look. High quality vinyl is usually quite indistinguishable from the “real thing”, complete with graining and texturing.

6. Allergies & Health

If you’re flooring a room in a space that is used by allergy sufferers it’s essential to consider their welfare – as well as the overall hygiene implications of vinyl and carpet.

Over time carpeting can trap allergens – even if it is well vacuumed frequently and steam cleaned periodically – and harbour things like dust mites and pet dander. Vinyl, on the other hand, is hypoallergenic and can be kept scrupulously clean relatively easily.

7. Cost

The professional fitting cost for vinyl flooring is not that different from that involved in laying fitted carpeting. As for the cost of the flooring material itself, that depends largely on the quality of the vinyl or carpeting you choose. You can go “cheap” on either product – essentially you get what you pay for. A high-end vinyl flooring option is generally less expensive per square metre than top of the range carpeting, but when it comes to cost this should not be the only consideration when choosing the right type of flooring. You could end up with practicing false economy.

8. Installation

In the hands of a specialist flooring company, there is little difference in the time and effort it takes to install vinyl flooring or carpeting. Vinyl could, depending on the complexity of the space and design, be slightly quicker to lay.

If you want to fit your own flooring as a DIY project, vinyl tiles or vinyl planks are much the easiest option – sheet vinyl is best left to the experts. Carpeting can be tricky to fit if you are inexperienced or lacking the proper equipment, and you could risk ending up with lumps and bumps!

If you live in or near the city of Bath in North-East Somerset and are wrestling with the choice of carpeting vs vinyl flooring, why not chat to the local experts. Paul Ealey Flooring Specialists will give you the benefit of their know-how with a free no-obligation consultation in Midsomer Norton, Peasedown St John, Radstock, or anywhere else in the area.

Dentons Local Business Experts
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.